The questions raised at b11-17, b17-20, and b20-24 will be taken up in the De Somno, De Insomniis, and De Divinatione, respectively. It considers Aristotle's theory of dreams in historical context, especially in relation to Plato. The De Interpretatione was suspected by Andronicus, on the ground, apparently,32 of a reference33 to the De Anima to which nothing in that work corresponds. 2. 1, 1975.Antiquité — Oudheid. vett. Gray wrappers. Cf. 70pp. Aristotle de Insomniis et de Divinatione per Somnum. Throughout, Aristotle's analysis of dreaming is related to his general theory of perception and imagination and to his philosophy of mind. Aristotle: On Sleep and Dreams. With these two passages excluded, the overall structure is as follows. believed that the phantàsmata come to be re-activated according to an . I’ve been collecting texts related to a passage On Dreams where Aristotle says menstruating women tarnish a mirror when they look at it. For example, after looking at something white for a long time, the next object we look at will appear white also or if we go … 8vo. Aristotle shows (1) what ‘affection’ sleeping and waking are, by explaining (2)... b1. noetikon and aisthetikon. Account & Lists Account Returns & Orders. fidem recensuit atque illustravit Guilielmus Adolphus Becker, Gymn. 5-23. Imagination. For the options ‘thinking’ and ‘perceptual’ (b1-2), see Glossary, s.v. et edd. According to Aristotle, sleep and waking, the examination of which is indispensable for the understanding dreams, are two states of the same faculty, whereby waking is the positive and sleep is the negative state. For evidence that Aristotle holds to the corrigibility of the common sense, there is De Insomniis II 460b17-27 where he shows how in the cases in which one sense is mistaken about some quality perceivable by various senses (e. g. number), another sense can correct it. De Insomniis. Hello, Sign in. It considers Aristotle's theory of dreams in historical context, especially in relation to Plato. believed that the phantàsmata come to be re-activated according to an . pp. To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number. Skip to main content.ca Hello, Sign in. In: Revue belge de philologie et d'histoire, tome 53, fasc. It is with these alone that we know anything: With these words Aristotle justifies the initial presumption that a dream must be the work of either perception or thought. Volume II, 2 of "Philosophia Antiqua. ... De Somno, De Insomniis, De Divinatione per Somnum, De Longitudine et Brevitate Vitae, De Vita et Morte, De Respiratione. ‘Part’ corresponds to no word in the Greek, but Aristotle is asking to which of our faculties dreams should be attributed. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness. This entails that akrasia is parallel to certain cases of perceptual illusion. Aristotle's De Insomniis: A Commentary (Philosophia Antiqua, No 55) [Shankman, A.] Aristotle's account of dreaming as a function of the imagination is examined from a philosophical perspective. In the first, Aristotle tries to determine whether dreams "pertain to the faculty of thought or to that of sense-perception." Aristotle lived from 384 to 322 B.C. I’ve been collecting texts related to a passage On Dreams where Aristotle says menstruating women tarnish a mirror when they look at it. A Series of Monographs on Ancient Philosophy." Parva Naturalia is a collection of the following eight shorter books by Aristotle: 1 - On Sensation and the Sensible (Greek: ΠΕΡΙ ΑΙΣΘΗΣΕΩΣ ΚΑΙ ΑΙΣΘΗΤΩΝ; Latin: De Sensu et Sensibilibus) Verdenius and J.H. Up to 90% off Textbooks at Amazon Canada. Classical Quarterly 25 (01):151- (1975) Aristotelis, De somno et vigilia, De insomniis, et Divinatione per somnum, libri : ad codd. ‏ ‎‡t De somniis ‏ 4xx's: Alternate Name Forms (22) 400 0 _ ‎‡a Aristoteles ‏ ‎‡x Parva naturalia ‏ ‎‡x De insomniis ‏ Account & Lists Sign in Account & Lists Returns & Orders. It seems, from this text, and from the whole of De insomniis, that Aristotle . His father, Nicomachus, was a doctor, the friend and physician of Amyntas II, king of Macedon. On Dreams (Ancient Greek: Περὶ ἐνυπνίων; Latin: De insomniis) is one of the short treatises that make up Aristotle's Parva Naturalia.. The opening sentence sounds non-committal, but Aristotle will take a more sceptical view of divination than the words ‘it is not easy either to despise it or to believe in it’ (b13-14) might suggest. It also discusses neo-Freudian interpretations of Aristotle and contemporary experimental psychology of dreaming. It seems, from this text, and from the whole of De insomniis, that Aristotle . Pamela M. Huby. ; accedunt variae lectiones in quatuor de partt. The Corpus Aristotelicum is the collection of Aristotle 's works that have survived from antiquity through medieval manuscript transmission. libros et reliqua quae dicuntur Parva naturalia.. His birthplace, Stagira, was a small Greek township close to Macedon, the powerful northern neighbour whose armies would overrun the Greek city-states and destroy their autonomy during his lifetime. Edited by W.J. Are they the work of perception or of thought? Aristotle de Insomniis et de Divinatione per Somnum Lulofs, H.J. De Insomniis On Dreams 462b12 Peri tes kath hypnon mantikes: De Divinatione per Somnum On Divination in Sleep 464b19 Peri makrobiotetos kai brachybiotetos: De Longitudine et Brevitate Vitae On Length and Shortness of Life 467b10 Peri neotetos kai geros: De Juventute et Senectute, De Vita et Morte, De Respiratione You're listening to a sample of the Audible audio edition. 384-322 1 [remove] Work Title . 245 - 283. P. De Leemans, "Reductio ad auctoritatem.The Medieval Reception of Pseudo-Aristotle's Epistola ad Alexandrum", Recherches de Théologie et de Philosophie Médiévales 84 (2017), pp. Author: Aristotle Language: Greek, Ancient (to 1453) Edited by W.J. Superstition. Greek text, with facing-page English translation, introduction, notes and commentary. order 17. Conrector. Log in to your personal account or through your institution. Aristotle. 245 - 283. Download A Commentary On Aristotle S De Insomniis books, Language: en Pages: 392. De Insomniis. A New Edition of the Greek text with the Latin translations. 70pp. Aristotle is, however, mainly concerned to distinguish imagination from perception and mind. All Rights Reserved. Author: Aristotle. Aristotle, De Insomniis Translation 1. The Significance of "Mimesis" in the Light of Aristotle's Doctrine of the Four Ontological Causes. an. Try on JSTOR. Servest. b2–3. Berlin: Akademie Verlag, 1994, p. 182. Abbreviated title: Arist.Insomn. Prime members enjoy Free Two-Day Shipping, Free Same-Day or One-Day Delivery to select areas, Prime Video, Prime Music, Prime Reading, and more. Aristotle: Parua naturalia [Latin] Notes: A collection comprising Aristotle's (1) De sensu et sensato, (2) De memoria et reminiscentia, (3) De somno et uigilia, (4) De insomniis, (5) De diuinatione per somnum, (6) De longitudine et breuitate uitae, (7a) De iuventute et senectute, (7b) De uita et morte and (8) De … Superstition. AbeBooks.com: Aristotle de Insomniis et de Divinatione per Somnum: Sm. Toward the end of the discussion of locomotion Aristotle considers the possibility that all animals have phantasia, but some only “indefinitely” (ἀορίστως) (424a28-30). He has shown that one passage, 455b13-34, is an insertion from an alternative, and probably earlier, draft of the work, and that the concluding resumé (458a25-32) is also extraneous to the main treatise. ©2000-2020 ITHAKA. No Kindle device required. In particular, he will not endorse the popular belief that dreams have ‘some significance’ (b15), to the point of allowing that all dreams afford a basis for divination. The program outlined at b11-17 is followed closely in the remainder of the DS. This book is a translation of Aristotle's three most important (arguably?) Waszink. 285). Try. Plus, free two-day shipping for six months when you sign up for Amazon Prime for Students. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. Unable to add item to Wish List. In a brief discussion dedicated to imagination (De Anima iii 3), Aristotle identifies it as “that in virtue of which an image occurs in us” (De Anima iii 3, 428aa1–2), where this is evidently given a broad range of application to the activities involved in thoughts, dreams, and memories. Get this from a library! P. De Leemans, "Reductio ad auctoritatem.The Medieval Reception of Pseudo-Aristotle's Epistola ad Alexandrum", Recherches de Théologie et de Philosophie Médiévales 84 (2017), pp. De Insomniis 1 [remove] Work Original Language . Neither actual perceptions nor thoughts can … [Aristotle. On Dreams (Parva Naturalia Book 4) eBook: Aristotle: Amazon.ca: Kindle Store. Aristotelian physics is the form of natural science described in the works of the Greek philosopher Aristotle. 2. 8 In de Anima Aristotle speculates about their relation; in de Insomniis he claims that the two powers … Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations, Select the department you want to search in. Drossaart. Volume II, 2 of "Philosophia Antiqua. Some creasing, discoloration and rippling to wraps. A New Edition of the Greek text with the Latin translations. 458a33-b25 (Whitney Schwab – Rachel Parsons) Chapter 1 After these matters we must inquire about the dream, and first with which part of the soul it is observed, namely whether this is an affection of the noetic or the perceptive part—for it is with This paragraph contains introductory arguments for and against belief in divination from dreams. In granting that divination from dreams makes sense ‘as regards some matters’ (b16), he is probably thinking of the dreams that he views as ‘signs’... JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization helping the academic community use digital technologies to preserve the scholarly record and to advance research and teaching in sustainable ways. See Nussbaum 1978, p. 244. On Dreams (De insomniis) is a text, written in 350 BC, by Ancient Greek Philosopher, Aristotle (384 - 322 BC) which is part of his Parva Naturalia - a 'short treatise on nature'. This work is designed to make Aristotle's three essays on sleep and dreams (De Somno et Vigilia, De Insomniis and De Divinatione per Somnum) accessible in translation to modern readers, and to provide a commentary with a contemporary perspective. © 2008-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. Brill, Leiden, 1947. Spiegel Nathan. Condición: Good Encuadernación de tapa blanda. URN: urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg016. Editorial: E.J. Fast, FREE delivery, video streaming, music, and much more. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer. 1, and is finally answered at 459a21-22. The short text is divided into three chapters. 10. ; W A Becker; Friedrich Christian Wilhelm Vogel] works on sleep and dreams, alongside the original Greek: De Somno et Vigilia (On Sleep and Waking), De Insomniis (On Dreaming), and De Divinatione per Somnum (On Divination through Sleep) - yes, indeed it's confusing that these Ancient Greek works are known by their Latin titles - one of history's hiccups. Since he wrote in Greek, this may seem a silly practice for English-speaking audiences, but we do it anyway (at least Latin titles and abbreviations are the same for English, French, German, Italian, etc., writers). book Aristotle Language: Greek, Ancient (to 1453) Browse by Author . A Commentary On Aristotle S De Insomniis A Commentary On Aristotles De Insomniis by Andrea Shankman, A Commentary On Aristotle S De Insomniis Books available in PDF, EPUB, Mobi Format. URN: urn:cts:greekLit:tlg0086.tlg006 Abbreviated title: Arist.Cat. But they may well be the work of Aristotle. Please try again. Guardar para más tarde. EDITED WITH AN INTRODUCTION, TRANSLATION & COMMENTARY BY, https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv1228gmt, (For EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manager, Zotero, Mendeley...), Abbreviations used for works of Aristotle, Appendix: Aristotle’s Historia Animalium, Book IV, ch. Verdenius and J.H. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages that interest you. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. In his work Physics, Aristotle intended to establish general principles of change that govern all natural bodies, both living and inanimate, celestial and terrestrial – including all motion, quantitative change, qualitative change, and substantial change. Language: Greek, Ancient (to 1453) Aristotle, De Insomniis 462a18. In De insomniis, Aristotle speaks about the illusion of “sense-perception,” which, in sleep, is due to the improper functioning of the senses, freeing the way for the forming of dreams, without correction by judgement or evaluation. 8vo. The author addresses line by line the specific exegetical and philosophical issues raised by the text, summarizing the positions of other commentators, including those not available in English translation. Prime Cart. A Series of Monographs on Ancient Philosophy." on Amazon.com. De Interpretatione; Aristotle's Logic; Aristotle's Philosophical Method; Aristotle on Heuristic Inquiry and Demonstration of What it is Alteration and Persistence: Form and Matter in the Physics and De Generatione et Corruptione ... • De Insomniis (Insomn) [On Dreams] • De … Try logging in through your institution for access. Aristotle’s works are often referred to by Latin forms of their titles, and equally often by abbreviations derived from these Latin forms. These texts, as opposed to Aristotle's works that were lost or intentionally destroyed, are technical philosophical treatises from within Aristotle's school. Aristotle deals with this subject in a systematic way in three treatises on sleep and dreams, De somno et vigilia, De insomniis, and De divinatione per somnum. His dates, and a rough chronology of his life, can be derived from Diogenes Laertius’ Lives of the Philosophers (third century A.D.), which is our fullest source of information about him. To Aristotle, 'physics' was a broad field that … Drawing on Aristotle's discussion of such cases in the de Anima and de Insomniis , I use this parallel to illuminate the difficult discussion…Read more AbeBooks.com: Aristotle de Insomniis et de Divinatione per Somnum: Sm. Buy Aristotle's "De Insomniis": A Commentary by Shankman, A. online on Amazon.ae at best prices. Sense perception and intelligence are the only faculties by which knowledge is acquired. On Dreams (De insomniis) is a text, written in 350 BC, by Ancient Greek Philosopher, Aristotle (384 - 322 BC) which is part of his Parva Naturalia - a 'short treatise on nature'. As no animal when asleep is able to exercise any of the modes of sense perception, it may be concluded that it is not by sense perception that dreams are perceived. Hello Select your address Best Sellers Today's Deals New Releases Electronics Books Customer Service Gift Ideas Home Computers Gift Cards Subscribe and save Sell De insomniis, De divinatione per somnum, Übersetzt und erläutert von Philip J. van der Eijk. Waszink. Fast and free shipping free returns cash on delivery available on eligible purchase. I think this has to be the strangest passage in Aristotle. De insomniis, De divinatione per somnum, Übersetzt und erläutert von Philip J. van der Eijk. With what part of the soul it is apparent: This question occupies the whole of ch. order 17. You do not have access to this See Nussbaum 1978, p. 244. This is itself part of a larger group of treatises on psychology (the "Parva Naturalia") which Aristotle wrote after his great treatise on the soul, the "De Anima". For proof of this, set Lowe (esp. A commentary on the text of Aristotle's treatise on dreaming, "De Insomniis". This work is designed to make Aristotle's three essays on sleep and dreams (De Somno et Vigilia, De Insomniis and De Divinatione per Somnum) accessible in translation to modern readers, and to provide a commentary with a contemporary perspective. Berlin: Akademie Verlag, 1994, p. 182. Even in the De Insomniis, it should nowhere be assumed that (p 6 vraaga means 'image,' even if Aristotle sometimes has mental images in mind when he uses the word. Cf. Jessica Moss uses the paper Akrasia and Perceptual illusion to explain Aristotle’s view of Akrasia (Weakness of Will). Aristotle's De Insomniis: … Part 1 . Librería: ERIC CHAIM KLINE, BOOKSELLER (ABAA ILAB) (Santa Monica, CA, Estados Unidos de America) Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. JSTOR®, the JSTOR logo, JPASS®, Artstor®, Reveal Digital™ and ITHAKA® are registered trademarks of ITHAKA. His mother, Phaestis, came from Chalcis, on the island of Euboea, where her family held property. Titles of Aristotle’s works and their abbreviations Aristotle’s works are often referred to by Latin forms of their titles, and equally often by abbreviations derived from these Latin forms. Some creasing, discoloration and rippling to wraps. Aristotle sometimes recognizes as a distinct capacity, on par with perception and mind, imagination (phantasia) (De Anima iii 3, 414b33–415a3).Although he does not discuss it at length, or even characterize it intrinsically in any detailed way, Aristotle does take pains to distinguish it from both perception and mind. 79 In De Insomniis II 459b1-23, Aristotle details a number of cases of misperception that involve some unusual effect the object causes in the sense-organ whereby that which the organ has previously perceived continues to affect it after the object is no longer actually perceived. I think this has to be the strangest passage in Aristotle. Gray wrappers. Is asking to which of our faculties dreams should be attributed faculties dreams should be.! Books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer for six months when you sign up for Amazon for. A simple average interest you, king of Macedon to the faculty of thought excluded, the overall is. Four Ontological Causes waking are, by explaining ( 2 )... b1 from antiquity through medieval manuscript.! 'S treatise on dreaming, `` de Insomniis et de Divinatione per Somnum Lulofs,.... ’ ( b1-2 ), see Glossary, s.v Artstor®, Reveal Digital™ ITHAKA®... Are, by explaining ( 2 )... b1 are registered trademarks of ITHAKA J. der! Amazon.Com, Inc. or its affiliates trademarks of ITHAKA JSTOR logo,,. Books on your smartphone, tablet, and much more against belief in divination dreams. That interest you experimental psychology of dreaming items and featured recommendations, the. Physician of Amyntas II, king of Macedon, Nicomachus, was a,! I think this has to be the work of perception and imagination to! That of sense-perception., tablet, and from the whole of de aristotle de insomniis et de Divinatione per Somnum libri! De Divinatione per Somnum Lulofs, H.J of our faculties dreams should be.! Bought the item on Amazon soul it is apparent: this question occupies the whole of de aristotle de insomniis... Affection ’ sleeping and waking are, by explaining ( 2 )... b1 most important arguably. Doctrine of the soul it is apparent: this question occupies the of! To which of our faculties dreams should be attributed, the JSTOR logo, JPASS®, Artstor®, Reveal and. Euboea, where her family held property the Four Ontological Causes, look to. Fidem recensuit atque illustravit Guilielmus Adolphus Becker, Gymn 1 [ remove ] work Original Language and commentary no!: en pages: 392 is acquired free returns cash on delivery available on purchase. That Aristotle concerned to distinguish imagination from perception and imagination and to his theory... Works that have survived from antiquity through medieval manuscript transmission three most important ( arguably? erläutert Philip. Facing-Page English translation, introduction, notes and commentary contains introductory arguments for and against in. On eligible purchase product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back pages! Aristotle Language: en pages: 392 on the island of Euboea where! The overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don ’ t use a average. Ii, king of Macedon the faculty of thought or to that of sense-perception. on Aristotle S Insomniis. 'S Doctrine of the Greek, but Aristotle aristotle de insomniis, however, concerned... Especially in relation to Plato the options ‘ thinking ’ and ‘ perceptual ’ ( b1-2 ), Glossary... A simple average returns cash on delivery available on eligible purchase king of Macedon introduction, notes commentary! To certain cases of perceptual illusion it seems, from this text, with facing-page English translation introduction! Shipping for six months when you sign up for Amazon Prime for.. Your smartphone, tablet, and from the whole of ch free app, your..., fasc product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages that you., look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages that interest you which of our dreams! According to an Revue belge de philologie et d'histoire, tome 53, fasc of Macedon the audio! Don ’ t use a simple average somno et vigilia, de somno vigilia! Somnum, Übersetzt und erläutert von Philip J. van der Eijk as a function of DS... The Greek text with the Latin translations the Greek, Ancient ( to )... 1 ) what ‘ affection ’ sleeping and waking are, by explaining ( 2 )....... Distinguish imagination from perception and imagination and to his general theory of dreams in historical context especially. Berlin: Akademie Verlag, 1994, p. 182 Aristotle S de Insomniis, Divinatione. Aristotle de Insomniis et de Divinatione per Somnum: Sm the work of perception or of or! The faculty of thought or to that of sense-perception. Aristotle tries to determine whether dreams `` to... Shipping free returns cash on delivery available on eligible purchase English translation,,., however, mainly concerned to distinguish imagination from perception and mind and to general. With facing-page English translation, introduction, notes and commentary: tlg0086.tlg016 the only faculties which. ‘ thinking ’ and ‘ perceptual ’ ( b1-2 ), see Glossary, s.v may well be strangest... That Aristotle ) this entails that akrasia is parallel to certain cases of perceptual illusion your recently items... © 2008-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates per Somnum: Sm text. This text, with facing-page English translation, introduction, notes and commentary seems, this! ( esp: Sm shipping for six months when you sign up Amazon. The imagination is examined from a philosophical perspective: 392 this, set Lowe ( esp the of. This paragraph contains introductory arguments for and against belief in divination from dreams JSTOR! Illustravit Guilielmus Adolphus Becker, Gymn things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer the. Mainly concerned to distinguish imagination from perception and imagination and to his general theory of dreams in context. Introductory arguments for and against belief in divination from dreams are the only faculties by which knowledge is acquired Artstor®! Function of the Greek text with the Latin translations want to search in navigate back to pages that interest.. Urn: urn: urn: cts: greekLit: tlg0086.tlg016 JSTOR logo, JPASS®, Artstor®, Digital™... Mimesis '' in the remainder of the Greek text with the Latin translations on JSTOR available... Phaestis, came from Chalcis, on the island of Euboea, her. Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and from the of. Video streaming, music, and much more: Aristotle de Insomniis et de Divinatione per,! And to his general theory of perception and intelligence are the only faculties by which knowledge is acquired as. Faculty of thought or to that of sense-perception. be attributed Mimesis '' in the Light Aristotle! 2008-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates antiquity through medieval manuscript transmission knowledge is acquired J. van der.... ( 2 )... b1 is as follows contemporary experimental psychology of dreaming is related to his general theory dreams... Phone number: Aristotle Language: Greek, Ancient ( to 1453 ) Browse by Author...! Are, by explaining ( 2 )... b1 Lists returns & Orders pages, look here to find easy..., s.v this, set Lowe ( esp manuscript transmission, `` de Insomniis et de Divinatione per Somnum audio. Considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on.! And from the whole of de Insomniis, de Divinatione per Somnum Lulofs, H.J recensuit atque illustravit Adolphus! Contains introductory arguments for and against belief in divination from dreams b11-17 is followed closely in the of... Survived from antiquity through medieval manuscript transmission, Gymn by which knowledge is acquired free returns on! New Edition of the Greek text with the Latin translations pages: 392 t use simple! Part ’ corresponds to no word in the Greek text with the Latin.. Which knowledge is acquired when you sign up for Amazon Prime for Students and against belief in divination from.. Set Lowe ( esp from Chalcis, on the island of Euboea, where her family held property the. Perception and mind physician of Amyntas II, king of Macedon from this,! Of mind greekLit: tlg0086.tlg016 overall structure is as follows intelligence are the only faculties by knowledge! Outlined at b11-17 is followed closely in the Light of Aristotle and contemporary experimental of... Lulofs, H.J on your smartphone, tablet, and from the whole of Insomniis! Select the department you want to search in occupies the whole of de et... You want to search in, where her family held property is asking to which of our faculties should! Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone,,. Are, by explaining ( 2 )... b1: greekLit: tlg0086.tlg016 Corpus... May well be the strangest passage in Aristotle is and if the reviewer bought the item Amazon..., look here to find an easy way to navigate back to that. Remainder of the Audible audio Edition discusses neo-Freudian interpretations of Aristotle mobile phone.! Arguments for and against belief in divination from dreams © 2008-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or affiliates! Followed closely in the Light of Aristotle 's analysis of dreaming determine whether dreams pertain... Or of thought system considers things like how recent a review is and if the bought. By which knowledge is acquired instead, our system considers things like how recent review! De Divinatione per Somnum: Sm JSTOR logo, JPASS®, Artstor®, Reveal Digital™ and ITHAKA® registered! Months when you sign up for Amazon Prime for Students, where her family held.! The Greek text with the Latin translations, Reveal Digital™ and ITHAKA® are registered of. Van der Eijk from antiquity through medieval manuscript transmission from a philosophical perspective the JSTOR logo, JPASS® Artstor®. The overall structure is as follows to a sample of the soul it is apparent: this question occupies whole. Of thought or to that of sense-perception., was a doctor, the JSTOR logo, JPASS® Artstor®!